On Thursday May 19, 2011 the breakfast stop was Kimberly’s Cafe and Creamery at 503 W High St in Carlisle. You may have read the review we gave them last year or noticed on our scorecard page that we rated Kimberly’s the #1 privately owned breakfast restaurant on the West Shore. Since then we have often wondered if we really rated them correctly, or if we were just really hungry that day, so a return visit was required to determine if Kimberly’s was really that good. Guess what, they are! Today was a great breakfast of large eggs, really good home fries, sausage links that were large and tasty, and even the toast seemed bigger than at other places. The service was great, the food came out quickly and I wasn’t sure if I would be able to finish it all. To be fair, I must note that Kimberly’s is not a real fancy place. It used to be a Baskin Robbins ice cream about 14 years ago and the inside has not changed too much since then. I noticed a few spots that could use a fresh coat of paint and some sprucing up, but it is still quite acceptable. I would deduct one point from their previous score, which gives them 20 out of 21 possible points, still an outstanding score that makes them one of the best places to eat on the West Shore. I would definitely go back again.