The Scorecard

Based on our own personal opinions and the average of our ratings, here are our scores:

(As of May 25, 2012)

#1 Momma Spriggs   20.5 / 21

#2 Kimberly’s Cafe & Creamery     20 / 21

#3 Caffe 101        20 / 21

#4 Summit Restaurant – Lewisberry  20 / 21

#5 Hi Life Diner     20 / 21

#6 L’ Koste Villa  20 / 21

#7 Yankee Doodle Diner   20  / 21

#8 Bakers Diner   19.5 / 21

#9 Peppermill     19.5 / 21

#10 Summit Restaurant – Camp Hill   19.5 / 21

#11 Marie’s Cafe       19.5 / 21

#12 The Chow Down Family Restaurant       19.5 / 21

#13 The Sunlight Diner   19.5 / 21

#14 Peppermill    19.5 / 21

#15 Diener’s   19.5 / 21

#16 Main Street Family Restaurant      19 / 21

#17 Camp Hill Cafe   19 / 21

#18 Pretzel Spot     18.5 / 21

#19 Hamilton Restaurant       18 / 21

#20 Village Square Diner    18 / 21

#21 Middlesex Diner   18 / 21

#22 West Shore Plaza Family Restaurant    18 / 21

#23 Tracks End   18 / 21

#24 Country Club Diner   18 / 21

#25 Colony House   17.5 / 21

#26 Dingledein Bakery 17.5 / 21

#27 Marysville Diner   17 / 21

#28 Silver Spring Diner    17 / 21

#29 Fairgrounds Diner    16.5 / 21

#30 TJ’s Homestyle        16.5 / 21

#31 Miseno’s Family Restaurant   16 / 21

#32 Carlisle Diner   16 / 21

#33 Fay’s Country Kitchen   16 / 21

#34 Country Chef    16 / 21

#35 John’s Hideaway Restaurant    15.5 / 21

#36 Bill’s Restaurant   15.5 / 21

#37 Farmers Market Restaurant  15 / 21

#38 Newberry Diner   14.5 / 21

#39 Summerdale Diner   14.5 / 21

#40 Colonial Park Diner  14 / 21

#41 Laura’s Family Restaurant     13.5 / 21

#42 Lemoyne Family Restaurant   13.5 / 21

#43 Beck & Don’s Kountry Kitchen  13 / 21

#44 Brother’s Family Dining   12 /  21

#45 Flapjacks (Paul’s Pancake Barn)  11 / 21

#46 Wolf’s Diner – Dillsburg     5 / 21

Angie’s Breakfast and Lunch – now closed

Mechanicsburg 50’s Diner – now closed

Brick House Restaurant – Now Closed

Walnut Cafe – Now closed

Camp Hill Diner – Now closed

Rupperts – Now Closed

Brick House Family Restaurant – Now Closed

Commercial Restaurants

#1 Perkins Family Restaurant      21 / 21

#2 Iron Skillet Restaurant    17 / 21

#3 Chick-fil-A         17 / 21

#4 Denny’s @ Flying J    16.5 / 21

#5 Denny’s – Mechanicsburg   16 / 21

#6 Friendly’s Restaurant   13.5 / 21

#7 Cracker Barrel      13 / 21

#8 The Waffle House – Carlisle     8.5 / 21

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s